Randisi & Associates

Pre-Employment Screening Specialists

RANDISI & ASSOCIATES, INC.

410.336.0287
Contact Us
  • Home
  • Services
    • Background Investigations
    • Drug & Alcohol Testing
      • Urine Specimen
      • Oral Fluid Testing
    • QuickApp and QuickApp Pro
  • About Us
    • Why Randisi Associates, Inc.?
    • Testimonials
    • Testimonials in Chesapeake Human Resources
    • Privacy Policy
    • Consumers
  • Resources
    • Marijuana in the Workplace
    • Employment Screening & Drug Testing
    • Negligent Referrals?
    • Interview with Larry Wilner
    • Drug Testing Seminars
  • Partners
  • News
    • Background Checks
    • Business Success
    • Drug Testing
    • Personnel Management
    • Employment News
  • Request A Quote
  • Contact Us
  • Client Login
    • CRL Order Form
  • Payment
You are here: Home / Personnel Management / Is Your Post-Offer Medical Exam ADA-Compliant?

Is Your Post-Offer Medical Exam ADA-Compliant?

April 19, 2019 By Jim Randisi

The post-offer medical exam process of JBS Carriers was subject to an EEOC Discrimination suit. As a result, the trucking company agreed to pay $250,000 to settle the disability discrimination lawsuit.

A description of facts in the lawsuit is available in the EEOC press release available here.

Our objective in this blog post is to highlight and provide comment to employers using post-offer medical exams. As always, we recommend using the services of competent legal counsel whether just beginning these types of medical reviews or evaluating your current program of medical reviews.

The EEOC alleged that the JBS Carrier process unlawfully screened out people with disabilities who were qualified for the truck driving jobs they sought. The screening subjected all applicants to a medical history questionnaire, a physical examination, and nine physical abilities tests.

The press release mentions that the process “unlawfully screened out people with disabilities who were qualified for the truck driving jobs they sought”. Obviously, then, the screening process used by JBS did not have an established relationship between the essential functions of the job and the tests given to applicants. This is a crucial step in developing the physical abilities tests.

“The screening subjected all applicants to a medical history questionnaire, a physical examination, and nine physical abilities tests.” After-offer medical history questionnaires can be a powerful tool if used properly. Primarily, they can remove individuals from the hiring process who are falsifying this company document. For example, let’s assume an applicant indicates they had no prior workplace injury claims against a previous employer. But you discover through investigation that they in fact did have a prior workplace injury claim, you can remove them from the hiring process not because of the existence of the injury but rather because they falsified your company document.

“The EEOC also alleged that by not giving individual consideration to job applicants, JBS Carriers discriminated against job applicants based on disability and failed to provide reasonable accommodations.” Again, it is crucial to assure that any decision to remove an individual from the hiring process based on any screening measures needs to be based on a direct correlation between the job’s essential functions and the individual’s ability to perform those essential functions. And, of course, employers need to make reasonable accommodations when appropriate. This question comes up frequently with our clients when considering an individual’s use of marijuana in states that allow medical marijuana.

“JBS Carriers halted the practice, and now only requires job applicants to obtain the Department of Transportation (DOT) medical certification necessary to be a licensed commercial truck driver.” This means that JBS Carriers decided to use a medical screen that had established links between the job’s essential functions and their ability to perform those job tasks. While JBS Carriers used an established government agency screen, that doesn’t mean an employer can’t implement a non-DOT process for non-DOT positions. What is important is that the screening process meet the criteria of being related to the job’s essential functions and accurately reflects the applicant’s ability to carry out those job tasks.

 

Filed Under: Personnel Management

Testimonials

Video testimonial from Rebecca Yarrison Miller's Minuteman Press Owings … Read More>>

Latest News

  • Pair of Companies in the Trucking Industry Says Positive Marijuana Tests And Federal Regulations Contribute to Driver Shortage
  • Supreme Court Ruling Just Changed the Rules for Cannabis Liability Cases
  • Five Things Not to Do When Giving Gifts to Customers and Employees
  • Random Drug Testing Regulations for Safety-Sensitive Positions Upheld
  • Understanding Adverse Action Steps in the Hiring Process

Afilliate Organizations

Tazworks NAPBS

Request A Quote

How can we Randisi and Associates assist your organization with background checks, drug testing and pre-employment screening?


CLICK HERE to Request a Quote or Consultation

Contact Us

Phone: 410.336.0287
Fax: 410.296.6131

1810 – J York Road PNB # 185
Lutherville, MD 21093
Contact Us

PRIVACY POLICY

©2025 Randisi & Associates, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Site by SPARKS!

We use cookies to make sure you get the best experience on our website. You can learn more by viewing our Privacy Statement.AcceptPrivacy Policy