This article from Fisher Phillips summarizes a recent change to previously issued guidance about using criminal records to make an adverse hiring decision.
EEOC Rescinds Criminal Records Guidance, but “Fair Chance” Laws Still Apply: 5 Steps for Employers
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) voted last week to immediately rescind its 2012 guidance on the use of arrest and conviction records in hiring, but employers that conduct criminal background checks still have complex rules to follow. The agency noted that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act still prohibits employers from discriminating against job applicants and employees based on protected characteristics, so this news doesn’t mean that employers have free rein now to automatically reject all candidates with criminal histories. The rescission also has no effect on the growing list of state and local “ban-the-box” and “fair chance” laws that regulate when and how employers can consider a job applicant’s criminal record. Here’s what happened, what it means for employers, and five steps you should consider taking now to ensure continued compliance.
The EEOC Votes to Withdraw the 2012 Guidance
The Commissioners voted 2-1 on October 28 to rescind Obama-era guidance that explained how the agency viewed criminal record screening under Title VII. Historically, the main concern was that broad employment policies, such as those that called for rejecting any applicant with a criminal conviction, could disproportionately screen out candidates based on race or national origin. The guidance encouraged employers to conduct an “individualized assessment” of an applicant’s record before making a hiring decision. [R&A Comment – We wrote a blog that summarized “individual assessments here.] The guidance also said Title VII was violated if an employer treated applicants of different races with the same convictions differently with regard to hiring decisions.
EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas said that rescinding the guidance “reaffirms the agency’s commitment to enforce Title VII consistent with the Constitution and the limits Congress placed on the EEOC’s authority” but it “does not give employers license to engage in unlawful discrimination.” She added that Title VII still prohibits race and national origin discrimination, including hiring requirements that are meant to disguise intentional discrimination.
The EEOC made two practical points in its announcement:
- The rescission doesn’t revive older EEOC policy statements that the 2012 guidance replaced.
- Employers aren’t required to scrap any lawful practices they adopted in response to the guidance.
Democratic Commissioner Kalpana Kotagal voted against the rescission. Protecting workers from overbroad criminal record screens “enables them to contribute to the economy and their communities, and to support their families,” she said in a statement.
Latest Move Away from Disparate Impact Claims
The EEOC’s vote last week is the latest in a series of actions shifting away from disparate impact enforcement. A disparate impact claim alleges that a neutral policy, like a criminal record screen, has a disproportionately negative effect on a protected group, even if it’s unintentional.
The agency’s new National Enforcement Plan, which was released in June, prioritizes disparate treatment (or intentional discrimination) claims over disparate impact claims. This aligns with President Trump’s 2025 Executive Order aiming to “eliminate the use of disparate impact liability in all contexts to the maximum degree possible.”
Chair Lucas has been clear that her priorities include rooting out unlawful DEI-motivated race and sex discrimination, as well as a commitment to “merit-based, evenhanded enforcement of our nation’s civil rights laws.”
But the disparate impact theory is still part of federal law. The U.S. Supreme Court has recognized disparate impact liability under Title VII since 1971 in Griggs v. Duke Power Co., and it was ultimately codified by Congress in the Civil Rights Act of 1991. In the Griggs case, SCOTUS found that requiring a high school diploma or a passing score on an intelligence test was unlawful because these practices had a disproportionate impact on Black employees and were not proved to be job-related. Notably, disparate impact liability has been recognized under other laws, including the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act, though the legal analysis varies.
State and Local Fair Chance Laws Still Apply
For many employers, state and local laws set stricter standards when it comes to criminal history inquiries during pre-hire background checks. Many states have “ban-the-box” or “fair chance laws,” and localities may impose additional requirements. Make sure to coordinate with your attorney and check your local area for specific laws that apply to your workplace.
You should also note that if you use a third-party background check provider to obtain criminal histories (among other types of information), the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) still requires a stand-alone disclosure, the applicant’s written consent, and specific notices before and after any adverse action is taken based on the screening.
A 5-Step Action Plan for Employers
Consider taking these five steps to keep your screening process fair and consistent across your locations:
- Review HR forms and practices. Be sure that job applications, internal candidate and promotion paperwork, and related selection processes are compliant with all applicable requirements. You should consider what, if any, changes you might make with regard to your evaluation of applicants with criminal histories in their background.
- Conduct an individualized assessment when necessary. Note that some state and local laws require this. Consider factors like the nature of the offense, how much time has passed, and the duties of the specific job. Document your decision-making process.
- Audit your disclosures and adverse action notices. Ensure your criminal background forms, notifications, and documentation practices comply with all federal, state, and local requirements for conducting investigations, as well as considering and taking adverse action. One of the most common mistakes occurs when an employer ignores or incorrectly follows FCRA’s requirements. Read more here about FCRA disclosures.
- Train HR teams and hiring managers regularly. Make sure managers know when they can ask about criminal history, how to handle adverse decisions, and which notices to send.
- Reach out to counsel. Many ban-the-box and fair chance laws involve complex requirements for employers that conduct criminal background investigations. Your attorney can help you create a robust plan to ensure compliance.
Conclusion
Fisher Phillips will continue to monitor developments related to criminal history screening and the EEOC’s enforcement priorities, so make sure you are subscribed to Fisher Phillips’ Insight System to get the most up-to-date information. If you have questions, contact your Fisher Phillips attorney, the authors of this Insight, or any attorney on our DEI and EEO Compliance Team or in our FCRA and Background Screening Practice Group.
James P. Randisi, President of Randisi & Associates, Inc., has been helping employers protect their clients, workforce and reputation through implementation of employment screening and drug testing programs since 1999. This post does not constitute legal advice. Randisi & Associates, Inc. is not a law firm. Always contact competent employment legal counsel. To learn more about the rights of employees who test positive for marijuana, Mr. Randisi can be contacted by phone at 410.336.0287 or Email: [email protected] or the website at randisiandassociates.com


