Leslie A. Lajewski and Steven J. Luckner, Shareholders in the law firm of Ogletree Deakins report on the U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey upholding an arbitrator’s award for an employee who was discharged after a positive marijuana test. The decision provides guidance to employers on the application of the New Jersey Cannabis Regulatory, Enforcement Assistance, and Marketplace Modernization Act (CREAMMA). [R&A Comment – And the decision provides guidance on the proper steps to establish impairment in the workplace. See underlined text below.]
The court found that the odor of marijuana alone is not sufficient to establish reasonable suspicion of cannabis use, possession, or impairment as required for an adverse action under CREAMMA.
Under CREAMMA, marijuana is legal for recreational use. Employers can require an employee to undergo a drug test when there is reasonable suspicion of an employee’s use of marijuana while on duty, when there are observable signs of marijuana intoxication, or following a work-related accident subject to investigation by the employer.
In April 2025, as an employee for County Concrete Corp. drove his personal vehicle during a lunch break past a supervisor and coworker on company property, the supervisor and coworker claimed that they detected a strong smell of marijuana from the vehicle. The supervisor ordered the employee to take a drug test, which returned positive for marijuana. The company fired the employee, who had previously tested positive for marijuana in December 2023. The employer had a two-strike policy, stating that two positive drug tests could result in termination of employment.
In December 2025, the arbitrator awarded the employee reinstatement to his former position. The arbitrator found that the company failed to establish the employee’s use of, possession of, or impairment from cannabis at the workplace.
The company argued that the arbitrator ignored CREAMMA when she considered the nonbinding best practices for employers published by the New Jersey Cannabis Regulatory Commission, including relying on observable, physical signs of impairment while on duty and documenting evidence within twenty-four hours or before drug test results arrive, and designating a point person with sufficient training to determine impairment. The union and the employee argued that an odor on clothing or in a car only established that marijuana may have been present at some prior time, not that an employee consumed the drug on an employer’s property or was impaired while on duty.
The U.S. District Court for the District of New Jersey noted that, in cases like this one concerning a collective bargaining agreement, courts must give deference to the arbitrator’s decision even if the arbitrator made errors in law or fact. An arbitrator’s award can only be vacated if it was procured by corruption, fraud, or undue means; if there was evident partiality or corruption in the arbitrator; if the arbitrator was guilty of misconduct in refusing to postpone a hearing or hear evidence; or if the arbitrator exceeded his or her powers.
In reviewing the arbitrator’s decision, the district court concluded that the arbitrator did not manifestly disregard CREAMMA or exceed her contractual authority. In confirming the award, the court explained that odor, standing alone, does not establish reasonable suspicion that an employee was using cannabis while performing his or her job duties or that the employee was impaired on employer property. The court noted that, in this case, “[t]here was no testimony that Grievant slurred his speech, no evidence that his eyes were glassy, and no evidence that he was impaired while on duty, and no report or evidence of poor work performance.” Further, the employer “allowed the Grievant to complete his shift until 4:30 pm that day without any reports of being impaired.”
The court made further reference to the fact that, contrary to best practices identified by the New Jersey Cannabis Regulatory Commission, the employer did not document the observance until more than a week later, and neither the supervisor nor coworker who observed the marijuana smell were trained in drug impairment recognition. The court found the arbitrator’s award was aligned with established legal precedent and was “rationally derived” from the collective bargaining agreement.
This case shows that, in New Jersey, the odor of marijuana and a positive drug test, without additional evidence, is not sufficient to justify an adverse employment action against an employee suspected of cannabis use, possession, or impairment. It also highlights the importance of drug impairment recognition training for individuals assessing an employee’s potential marijuana use.
Employers in New Jersey may wish to review their employee handbooks and collective bargaining agreements to ensure compliance with state laws regarding drug testing and off-duty marijuana use.
Ogletree Deakins’ Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution Practice Group and the Drug Testing Practice Group will continue to monitor developments and will post updates on the Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution, Drug Testing, and New Jersey blogs as additional information becomes available.
James P. Randisi, President of Randisi & Associates, Inc., has been helping employers protect their clients, workforce and reputation through implementation of employment screening and drug testing programs since 1999. This post does not constitute legal advice. Randisi & Associates, Inc. is not a law firm. Always contact competent employment legal counsel. To learn more about the rights of employees who test positive for marijuana, Mr. Randisi can be contacted by phone at 410.336.0287 or Email: [email protected] or the website at randisiandassociates.com


